Ontario police crack cold case from 1975, charge Florida man with murder

Ontario Provincial Police say they have cracked a decades-old cold case and charged a man with the murder of a woman who was found dead in eastern Ontario 48 years ago.

Police say they have identified a woman found dead east of Ottawa in 1975 as Lalla Jewell Parchman Langford, who was 48 at the time.

The remains of the victim were found on May 3, 1975, floating in the Nation River near the Highway 417 bridge and the unidentified woman was known for decades as the “Nation River Lady.”

“Today we have a significant to one of the oldest, unsolved, and most unique unidentified remains investigations in OPP history,” says Marty Kearns, deputy commissioner of OPP Investigations and Organized Crime, in a Wednesday morning news conference.

“We have provided a resolution to her family and to the communities in eastern Ontario that have lived with this unsolved investigation for more than 47 years.”

Police say, Rodney Nichols, an 81-year-old man who resides in Florida, has been charged with murder. OPP tells CityNews that Nichols is believed to be living in Hollywood, Florida and has not yet been taken into custody.

“While the charge was formally laid before the court late last year, at the Ontario Court of Justice in L’Orignal, the OPP did not announce this publicly at the time,” police said.

“Prematurely sharing developments in the investigation could have jeopardized the investigation and ensuing court processes, including potential extradition from the United States.”

Court documents obtained by the Canadian Press show that Nichols was charged in September with murdering Langford between April 22 and May 3, 1975.

Det.-Insp. Daniel Nadeau said the 48-year-old woman was a well-known member of the business community in Jackson, Tenn., who co-owned a spa with her ex-husband.

He said she had travelled to Montreal in April 1975 and never returned home.

“At that time, her family in Tennessee had reported her missing,” he said.

“While I cannot get into the specifics that will be entered at trial, I can tell you that the accused and the victim were known to each other.”

Nadeau said police have tried to identify the victim over the years using different methods, including creating a 3D facial approximation of her in 2017, but had no success.

He said the Centre of Forensic Sciences in Toronto obtained a new DNA profile of the victim in 2019.

Nadeau said the DNA data was sent to a lab in California where the DNA samples matched those collected from two individuals listed in a family DNA tree.

The DNA Doe Project, an organization that works to identify victims in cold cases, said the woman was identified after OPP contacted them for help on the case in 2019.

The organization said a DNA profile for the victim was uploaded to genetic genealogy databases in 2020 and its team of volunteers identified Langford as a likely candidate within a few weeks.

Ontario Chief Coroner Dr. Dirk Huyer said the DNA profile was used to help establish possible connections between the victim and others.

Huyer said DNA samples were then obtained from the surviving relatives of Langford, including her nieces.

“That information was brought back to the Center of Forensic Science in Ontario and identification was confirmed through that DNA comparison work that was done,” he said.

“This was a long, ongoing process, never stopping.”

Police say Langford’s remains were repatriated to the United States in March of 2022 and a memorial service and burial were held for her.

Western University criminologist Michael Arntfield, who studies cold cases, said the Langford case marked an interesting use of DNA genealogy technology because it included both an unsolved homicide and an unidentified victim.

He said DNA genealogy analysis has been used in the United States to solve cold cases or put a name on unidentified human remains for several years.

“To see a convergence of unidentified remains and homicide for which a suspect has been identified simultaneously resolved using this method is really a breakthrough,” he said.

He said the high cost of using this investigative method is prohibitive for some police forces.

But, he added, “there are resources available to defray those costs as well as opportunities for police leaders to realign where the resources are placed.”